Fair Trade

The true cost of chocolate- Article from the GlobeandMail. May 12th 2023

The true cost of chocolate by GEOFFREY YORK AND ADRIAN MORROW


Labels for ‘sustainable’ cocoa can hide harsh realities for farmers trying to earn a living and eliminate child labour. In Africa and Latin America, The Globe spoke with growers on the front lines of global price wars.Canadian consumers, seeing labels that boast of “100-per-cent sustainably sourced cocoa” on many of the most popular chocolate products in Canada’s supermarkets, might never imagine that hunger and poverty are the grim daily reality for millions of cocoa farmers in Africa and Latin America.

Sustainable cocoa – a promise of all the major cocoa and chocolate companies – is vaguely defined and can include anything from training and education programs to a variety of supply certification schemes that pay premiums and attempt to trace cocoa origins. But at the heart of the sustainability concept is a pledge by the major manufacturers to help farmers gain a decent income. The promise is crucial to their marketing: a reassuring signal to consumers that a chocolate purchase is an ethical one.

READ THE REST OF THE ARTICLE


Chocolate, café y té 'Comercio Justo': El fraude más grande del siglo

Por

Fernando Morales-de la CruzFounder of Café for Change13/07/2019 09:44am CEST

La Coordinadora Estatal del Comercio Justo, la red mundial de la organización Alemana Fairtrade International, la Comisión Europea y también organizaciones del sistema de Naciones Unidas y ONG como Oxfam y Cáritas hacen creer a periodistas, a políticos y a los consumidores que “con el ‘Comercio Justo’ colaboramos con el desarrollo de las comunidades del Sur” cada vez que consumimos un chocolate, un café, un té, etc, supuestamente certificado como “Comercio Justo”.

Es absolutamente falso que “con el ‘Comercio Justo’ colaboramos con el desarrollo de las comunidades del Sur”.

En su testimonio en el Parlamento Europeo Ange Aboa, corresponsal de Reuters para África del Oeste y Central, dijo que el sistema de certificaciones Comercio Justo/Fairtrade, UTZ y Rainforest Alliance “son el fraude más grande del siglo” (“La plus grosse scroquerie du siecle”). Es posible escuchar el testimonio de Ange Aboa en francés aquí.

Read the rest of the article

Do You Really Want Change?--By Erin Andrews of Indi Chocolate

Do You Really Want Change?

Many of the familiar candy bars we’ve grown up with, passed out for
Halloween, and chocolate we’ve baked into holiday treats, contain
ingredients created by enslaved child labor. This candy is available
now at a store near you, but the low, low prices are only possible
because of business practices that would turn your stomach.

Lawyers representing Nestle and Cargill were in the Supreme Court
yesterday because the companies for decades chose ingredients that
they knew were grown and processed with enslaved child labor.

The largest, most profitable multinational chocolate corporations
confirm they were aware the children were working without pay or
liberty, and that they were not working on their own family farms.
These corporations have publicly confirmed that they are buying
ingredients that they know use internationally trafficked children.

The case before the Supreme Court is not about whether these practices
exist today, or who knew about them. The question is why these large,
profitable US corporations have been able to get away with this for so
long without accountability or consequences.

They have long acknowledged the problem but have made no meaningful
progress in solving it, despite having the resources to do so.

Let’s be honest. Choosing to not take action will continue the problem
It doesn’t resolve it.

Choosing profits over ethics prolongs unacceptable colonial traditions.

Can we, as Americans, finally acknowledge that these corporations are
not going to change unless there are consequences? At what point is
the cost of not actually doing what is ethical, decent and right
become too much, unacceptable and intolerable? These corporations are
making conscious choices to see how long they can get away with it.

At what point do the corporation’s continued broken promises and lack
of meaningful action have consequences? How long are we going to allow
them to get away with this?

These are important questions the Supreme Court and US citizens need
to address right now.

This case before the Supreme Court is about making these corporations
accountable and having consequences for not really doing anything
about it. Shouldn’t there be consequences if that is the only thing
that will finally make these corporations do what they promised and
could have changed long ago?

These US corporations shouldn’t be exempt from laws and accountability
because they pretend that they are going to resolve this issue at some
date pushed further and further into the future when all they have
proven to us so far is they have made a choice to try to get away with
it for as long as they can.

Shouldn’t the US judicial system hold these US corporations legally
accountable for their actions (and knowingly choosing to not take
meaningful action) even when they occur out of sight in a faraway
country?

When is the US Justice System, and laws of our nation that make the US
such an economic powerhouse, going to give these corporations
meaningful consequences so they will finally make the change?

When US corporations enjoy the many benefits like freedom of speech,
laws and judicial process that are fundamental to doing business (such
as enforceable contracts and reliable, dependable financial
institutions), as well as use of our public assets (from our taxpayer
investment in roads, bridges, and airwaves to defense spending
investment that created GPS and the Internet they use), shouldn’t
these corporations also be held responsible too?

Here is our opportunity to do what is right. Our US corporations
should reflect American leadership and values.

America has a choice to make. This is our time to lead and not follow.

Please let our US Supreme Court justices know how important our
integrity and values are as a nation, a people and a US corporation.
Let us be leaders of doing what is right so we can hold our heads
high.

If you would like to support more ethical chocolate companies, put
your money where your mouth is and vote with your dollars,
www.slavefreechocolate.org has many suggestions.

Erin Andrews
Founder and CEO of indi chocolate (Seattle, WA)
Co-Founder of Cotton Tree Chocolate (a Belize company)

Recent Question Regarding Nestlè, by Ayn Riggs

Question: I always seek out only fair trade chocolate. I always avoided Nestle and Hershey, but recently heard on a radio segment that Nestle had done a lot to ensure their chocolate was not coming from unethical sources. Your site, however, suggests nothing much has changed. Is Nestle doing any better? Or should I return to my chocolate chip-less ways?

SFC’s Answer: Thank you for writing in. Do you remember where you heard that radio segment? If so, pass it on. I may be able to hear an archive of it. But to answer your question, Nestle is lying. Sure they have made some paltry initiatives so that they can take a photo of some kids in front of a single school they may have built but only to dupe consumers.

There are really only about 6 companies that purchase the 60% of cocoa tied to child labor and slavery and Nestlè, as well as Hershey, are right there. They all say that they are doing their part in ensuring that their cocoa is traceable. If that were the case then the numbers (of children at risk) by the US Dept. of Labor would be going down and not up.

These farmers that are at the end of the supply line about 800,000 of them have tiny plots of land (about 4 hectares). They are deep in the bush where there is no electricity, schools or access to medical care. They don' thave cars either. They harvest their beans and put them on a road and a middle man hands them some cash. They make about .50 cents a day which is 2/3 below the poverty line. If they don't have enough of their own children, they may resort to buying some, under a tree in a makeshift auction.

Additionally, without infrastructure farmers are practicing poor farming techniques. Where a cocoa tree should last a good 40 years, these are lasting about 3 to 4. So these farmers are going into protected forests and deforesting the native trees with Round-up. I am sure they use this on more legit farms but are absolutely soaking the ground with this so that they can plant more cocoa trees. If you go to our FB page and scroll down you will see a video from a French reporter. You don't need to speak French to understand it. https://www.facebook.com/Slave-Free-Chocolate-185449184662/?ref=bookmarks

I think you can find Fair Trade chocolate chips online. I believe Equal Exchange makes them!

Thanks for writing in and caring about this issue.



Interview with cocoa bean wholesaler, Juan Gonzalez of MABC.

Interview:  Juan Gonzalez owner 

of The Mexican Arabica Bean Company 

by Ayn Riggs of SlaveFreeChocolate.org November 9th, 2019

SFC:  How did you come to work in the coffee and cocoa bean industry? 

JG:  All my life I have been working in the coffee and cocoa beans. When I was a child, I worked in the plantations helping my mother in the harvest season and just about 10 years ago I started working again but now an importer and seller.

SFC: When did you hear about child labor problems in West Africa? 

JG: All my life I’ve known about it, this is not a new history always. It has been since colonial times. 

SFC: Can you tell me about your experiences harvesting cocoa in your youth?

JG: We get up at 4 am to start working, we use to live in the farms ground for the season and after we finish, we move to another province and another farm, I start working since I was 8 years old.

 

SFC: Do you see a potential child labor problem arising in Central or South America?

JG: Not that same level as Africa, but there are a lot of possibilities. A lot of farms using one kind of child labor, all dependent on the local government, which can see this kind the problem can raise in Asia. 

 

SFC: There is a vastly growing number of small bean to bar chocolatiers that are buying ethically sourced cocoa, aside from this, can you think of other ways they can help in the industry in regard to child labor and slavery?

JG:  We have 2 problems here, most of all the small chocolate makers do not buy directly, they don't have any idea about these big problems. They love self-promotion and push their brands. It is very costly for a small chocolate company to buy beans directly. Their chocolate bars would have to cost $15 a piece. So, they buy from me and put on their packages that they purchase their beans directly.  Sometimes they take a trip to cocoa farms for some selfies and return home. 

Some buy small portions of the cocoa beans directly then fill the gap with cheap slave tainted chocolate.  

 

SFC: What do you see going forward is the biggest challenge for chocolatiers and cocoa wholesalers? JG: Prices and values. Why because fine flavors cocoa bean with all the certifications can cost 3 times more the conventional, you have to remember chocolate is a luxury product and not a necessity like milk, eggs, bread or vegetables even coffee, so high prices, and social conciseness can be a big challenge to be in business.  I’ve been in this industry for 30 years and there is still a lot of poverty in the coffee and cocoa bean industry despite the Fair-Trade movement. Certification and cost are so big plus they not helping in anything to places of origin, the only good thing is the farmer can sell a higher price if the market they are low 

 

SFC: What do you do aside from sourcing ethical cocoa to aid the plight of the farmers and their children?

JG: Well every year we have been collecting school supplies and backpacks and send to Honduras to the co-op the I working within buying coffee and cocoa beans, together we promote SAID NOT A CHILD LABOR  I start that idea and I find the support the I need in deliver the supplies to the local schools and places where the kids of farmers attending school, 

 

SFC: How do you see climate change affecting your supply of coffee and cocoa beans?

JG: It affects everything, not just the coffee and cocoas beans supplies but all food supplies, the trees they are changing when the flower starts also the despair of the bees who is the most important helper but this is a big-picture  the humans have a big part in this and they can help and change but only the planet has the last word. 

 

SFC: What are you most passionate about in regard to your business?

JG: See the happy faces of the farmers and think the with my support I can help just a little be in their lives  

 

SFC: What type of chocolate is your favorite?

JG: I don't eat chocolate; I just taste, and I love the nips and the beans I eat all day long raw and roast they give me a lot of energy ;) 

 

From the Washington Post dated 10/23/19 By Peter Whoriskey "Chocolate companies ...

Chocolate companies sell ‘certified cocoa.’ But some of those farms use child labor, harm forests.

Utz, the largest cocoa certifier, found “alarming” problems at four firms responsible for auditing a large portion of the world’s supply.

By

Peter Whoriskey

Oct. 23, 2019 at 11:32 a.m. CDT

The leading organization responsible for policing standards in the world’s cocoa industry has regularly approved cocoa from West African farms that use child labor or have contributed to deforestation of the region, interviews and research show.

Read the full article here.

Stanisland--Interview with Ayn Riggs

stanisland October 9, 2019 Compass

12 Questions For Ayn Riggs Of Slave Free Chocolate

When you walk by a chocolate shop, the scent of cocoa aroma busts down the door of your nostrils compelling you to buy. The Aztecs first grew cocoa thousands of years ago, and the world has since traded it as a luxury item, commodified and distributed as an integral part of the global economy. Read More here